Could I use less sugar maybe 1/2 cup instead of 3/4 cup? Always a good sign to come home with an empty pan - ha. And for those that think it's too sweet, maybe you shouldn't be looking at dessert recipes. Thank you for supporting Shugary Sweets! As someone who always keeps yellow platanos, or plantains, handy on my kitchen counter or in my freezer, I'm always looking for new ways to make use of them. We're sorry, there seems to be an issue playing this video. Sometimes sipping a stiff drink and taking in a movie is the best way to unwind. However, I only recommend products I love! The caramel syrup is delicious. Search in title . Required fields are marked *. In a shaking glass with ice, combine whipped cream vodka, creme de banana, milk, banana pudding mix, and yellow food coloring (optional). There are variations in the way its served and prepared and Ive listed some adaptations in the post below, including a more traditional Southern Banana Pudding. And skipping the mascarpone or cream cheese all together works too. partytime-liquor.com, best I want at least a piece of banana in every bite. Affiliate Disclosure:**There may be affiliate links in this post! Remove from the heat and cool for 10 minutes. Copyright 2023 Your Name Here. To keep the bananas from turning brown too quickly, you can sprinkle a little citric acid powder onto the sliced bananas. My family and friends alike really compliment me when I have this dessert. KitchenAid 5-Speed Ultra Power Hand Mixer. Absolutely love this recipe Made it and oh my every little bit was gone My family and friends have asked for the recipe yummy yummy yummy , 2023 Cond Nast. Pudding Filling. Top with sliced bananas. Crush reserved vanilla wafers and sprinkle over the whipped cream. Whisk 2 packets of pudding powder with the sippin' cream and milk. Add sweetened condensed milk and beat until combined. This cream liqueur offers a deep, rich taste paired with an ultra-smooth finish sure to satisfy the banana-lover in</p> I tried it after 2 hours and then again the next day. Change Location Quantity Add to Cart, Buy Sugarlands Banana Pudding Appalachian Sippin' Cream | ReserveBar Sugarlands Banana Pudding Appalachian Sippin' Cream offers a deep, rich taste paired with an ultra-smooth finish sure to satisfy the, 1 1/2 cups of Banana Pudding Sippin' Cream 1 package of Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix (3.4 ounces) 1/2 cup of cold milk 2 tsp. . Arrange a layer of vanilla wafers in the bottom of a deep, 8-inch square or 2-quart baking dish. Set aside. You mix it in with the rest of the ingredients! It is made with rum, cream liqueur, and natural flavors and bottled at 40 proof. With the perfect pudding-to-cookie ratio, this delightfully sweet and creamy banana pudding tastes real in comparison to boxed pudding mixes. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Someone below added walnuts, the only thing I added was chopped pecans for a little crunch. Each 5-day meal plan includes a printable grocery shopping list with budget information, to help save time and money! I know what it's like and you feel like you totally wasted ingredients. If you don't mind a little brown on your bananas, they are perfectly fine to use and should be very sweet which is a good thing. timeout Top with a single layer of sliced bananas. I think the sweetness level is perfect! Whipped cream or meringue? Required fields are marked *, I made the Banana Pudding following the recipe, except I used one each 3.5 ounce Banana Cream and one Cheesecake INSTANT PUDDING. Cookies. Fold it gently into the other ingredients. Top with sliced bananas, then of the pudding mixture. Finally, be sure to plan ahead, as the vanilla pudding needs to be chilled for an hour before you assemble the whole shebang and the finished dish needs to chill for about 6 hours before serving. Is it sweet, yes, but it is a phenomenal pudding recipe. In a mixing bowl, beat cream cheese with sweetened condensed milk until smooth. Whisk 2 Tbsp. Serve immediately. It did set up too thick, so I slowly whisked in more cream a little at a time until I got the consistency I needed. these links. I created this space for anyone who is experiencing the change that comes when your children leave home. or 8x8" baking dish or pan. You can read mydisclosurepage for more information. Cooking advice that works. 2023 Warner Bros. Pour the mixture over ice cube in a glass and top up with the chocolate syrup. Tennessee- Aromas of banana pudding, vanilla, and cream. Although the mascarpone may be adding to the runniness as it will only stay good for 3-4 days in the fridge. My brother cant stand the taste of it, so I wanted to make sure that the disgusting tang (as he describes it ) doesnt shine through the other flavors. Originally published: February 2014Updated & Republished: April 2019. I don't bake or make desserts, but just exactly how long should the ingredients have been mixed. Or go easy and whip up this banana pudding cake! Very slowly pour in a little of the milk mixture, you have to do it slowly to temper the mixture, (otherwise the eggs will scramble). Top with sliced bananas, then of the pudding mixture. 1 1/2 cups of Banana Pudding Sippin' Cream 1 package of Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix (3.4 ounces) 1/2 cup of cold milk 2 tsp. The Full Nester | 2017-2023 | All Rights Reserved. I dont recommend freezing banana pudding. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and place the assembled dessert in the fridge for 4-8 hours. Be sure to use instant pudding not cook and serve for best results. You can find it at good liquor stores. The bananas will brown a bit and the pudding may loosen, but the flavors and textures hardly suffer, and with a dessert this good, you wont even notice. Classic banana pudding's vanilla custard is made with flour not corn starch and the layers of pudding, sliced bananas and vanilla wafers are topped with meringue and then baked to brown the meringue. You cant even make what youre talking about. Whisk milk, sugar, flour, and salt together in a medium saucepan until well combined. This was sooooo good and extremely EASY!!!! I waited about an hour and a half then put the popsicle sticks in. Beat cream to stiff peaks. 3. I followed the recipe to a T. Kind of disappointing. Thank you. Place a piece of plastic wrap directly on top (to prevent a skin from forming on it). Price and stock may change after publish date, and we may make money off = Combine and add shot of your whiskey. (If you arent using the mascarpone, add the banana and sweetened condensed milk when you transfer the warm pudding from the saucepan to the large bowl.). I used mascarpone, but didn't taste any tang at all, just an almost cloying sweetness. Delectable Desserts . Photo by Emma Fishman, food styling by Kat Boystova, prop styling by Allie Wist. LOL. My husband and I love it. Transfer to a bowl and cover with plastic wrap, pressing the wrap onto the surface so it doesn't form a skin on the surface. Eating ice cream with an equally cold spoon is just the way to go. Banana Pudding Cream No Southern potluck is complete without a giant pan of banana pudding, the beloved dessert that inspired our Banana Pudding Cream Liqueur. For Ice cold water | Fill measuring cup or bowl with 1 1/2 cups water and ice, let sit for a minute, pour into liquid measuring cup (keeping the ice out) for ice cold water, or use cold water from the fridge. The only complaint was that there was not more of it. This is probably the least sweet banana pudding you will find but i still found it a bit sweet. Uncategorized . Im Lauren, a mom of four and lover of good food. Im a regular home cook, like most of you, doing my best to get a good meal on the table for my family. I love this pudding. Banana Pudding Sippin' Cream honors a classic southern dessert bursting with flavors of banana, vanilla wafers, whipped cream, and sweet pudding. 21 Finally, stir in half of the whipped topping. My husband said it tasted just like what his grandmother used to make. We are the winners when it comes to quality food with the right ingredients which will impact positively your body system. Be sure to serve it in a lovely ice cream dish, and use a real silver spoon if possible. I mentioned that next up was Banana Pudding Sippin Cream. I made it for guests who arent from the US and Im embarrassed to serve it to them. If youre a chocolate lover, this recipe is just for you. Whisk the egg yolk mixture back into the hot milk mixture and continue to cook, stirring constantly, until thick and creamy, about 5 minutes. Meanwhile, whisk the sugar, cornstarch, and salt together in a medium saucepan to remove any lumps. Again, just coat lightly so as not to change the flavor. Fold in the banana slices. This memorable artichoke appetizer comes to the table with a bowl of Rigazzi's marinara sauce, perfect for dipping these artichoke hearts stuffed with a tomato-basil cream cheese, then hand On Wednesday nights at Sonny's Gelato Caf in Boca Raton, you too can be serenaded while relaxing outdoors, the wind caressing your hair as you lick a nutella and banana gelato Betty's keeps it simple bread pudding, cake, and sweet potato pie. So this started out to be something else. Some folks don't enjoy the artificial banana flavoring in the banana cream instant pudding but this is entirely a personal preference. And by homemade, I mean, not store-bought. See blog post for more recipe tips and tricks. Starbucks Is Putting Olive Oil in Its Drinks Is This the Next Revolution in Coffee? At least I have time to make something else thats less gross before tomorrow. Repeat layers once more, using half of the remaining pudding. Love, love, love hearing that Jessica!! This post may contain affiliate links. So if you want a different way to enjoy the flavors of banana pudding, I hope youll give Banana Pudding Sippin Cream Ice Cream a try! In the south we know our nana puddin and this one is a good one!!!! Everyone loved it! But platanos upside down cake? Hummingbird cake is the best option if you crave something sweet and exotic. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with an electric mixer on medium speed until smooth and fluffy. If using salted butter, eliminate salt from the recipe. I suspect it is because of the alcohol content in the Sippin Cream. I highly recommend this recipe. Stir in the butter and vanilla and remove from heat. However, when you buy something through the retail links below, we earn an affiliate commission. I watched my granny make it for years and have never been able to make it as good as she did. Place the milk and banana chips in a small saucepan over medium heat, bring to a simmer, and cook for 10 minutes. You might think sweetened condensed milk would make for a cloyingly sweet banana pudding, but fear not! Its okay if the pudding is still quite loose at this stage. 3.4 oz instant banana pudding 1 1/4 cup whole milk 1/2 cup Cool Whip For the Cool Whip Layer: 1 1/2 cups Cool Whip (remaining from an 8oz container) Instructions For the Cookie Crust Grind up Vanilla Wafer Cookies in a blender, until a fine crumb is reached. Bananas, whipped cream, vanilla wafers, and booze. thefullnester.com, top Everyone has different opinions about it. Still, this is more of a mixing whisky than a sipping one buttery and brittle with a little bit of green banana sneaking in next to cream soda and apple candies. More about me, 2023 Shugary Sweets. Dip into The Sip, our lifestyle and entertaining blog featuring all things Southern Social. I would add a teaspoon of banana extract too and there will be no way he can taste it. You will notice that as I add the wafers, I face some outwards and up the sides. Super simple and easy! Pour the mixture over ice cube in a glass and top up with the chocolate syrup. Time to layer. Add cornstarch and mix to combine. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); With me at WinRecipe.com, you can be sure of getting the right recipe that will give you true cover all through the day and the week as a whole. I used 6 medium size bananas, and cover the bottom so you dont see any cookies (about 2 layers worth of banana slices). I did use mascarpone both batches as well. I recommend removing it from your recipe library. Once combined, add milk and place over medium-high heat, whisking until combined. With homemade vanilla pudding, sweetened condensed milk (the secret ingredient no one talks about), and mascarpone, this truly is the best (and easiest) banana pudding recipe. It fades with dairy cream, and Banana Laffy Taffy. Set aside. Please refresh the page or try again in a moment. Bottom Layer. Your email address will never be published. Please refresh the page or try again in a moment. This Banana Pudding is just awful! I'm doing just that, and you can read more about it here! Then pour one-third of the pudding mixture on top (enough to cover all the bananas). Hi Ernestine, no it won't set up properly without it. 4 Easy and Healthy Breakfast Recipes You Should Try, 5 Delicious Instant Pot Chicken Breast Recipes for Quick and Easy Meals, Take A Look At The Best Sellers Of Chili Candy Mixes, Most Delicious Mahi Mahi Air Fryer Recipe, Sweet and Sour Sauce Recipe to Make the Best Homemade Sauce, Publix Cajun Crab Dip Recipe Make Spicy Cajun Crab Dip. Stir constantly until it comes to a simmer and the mixture thickens enough that it coats the back of a wooden spoon. Theres nothing less appetizing than brown or dark bananas in your banana pudding. My family loved it. (Pro tip: mix it in your grandmas banana pudding recipe and thank us later). In a mixing bowl, combine cream cheese with sweetened condensed milk. The pudding is barely sweetened and the mascarpone adds a subtle tang and slight acidity. Make crust: In a medium bowl, combine crushed Nilla wafers with butter, sugar, and salt. Perhaps the mascarpone I used wasn't the best. Chill. Perfect for weeknights or potlucks, everyone will LOVE this classic recipe! 2023 Tastes Better From Scratch Privacy Policy and Disclosure. I followed the directions and ingredients precisely, including making sure the whipped cream was very stiff, but the pudding mixture was runny. I rarely eat added sugar, so if youre the same, find another recipe honestly one thats just sweetened with bananas and maybe a couple of tablespoons of sugar would be plenty. Bring to a simmer, stirring often. And yes, SHUGARY is spelled correctly. Ad Choices, large or 6 medium bananas (about 1 lb. Beat until creamy, with no clumps! Instructions. Thank you for this recipe. The write-up suggested that "mascarpone adds a subtle tang and slight acidity." Then I split it into two 9-inch square pans. It might just be the best I've ever made! Dang it!!! Unless otherwise noted, all images and content here onThe Country Cook are original and copyright protected under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The sweetness of the bananas and the tanginess of the pineapple make this dish stand out. Fold in the Cool Whip, and add the cinnamon. ), divided, cup mascarpone or room-temperature cream cheese (optional), Coconut Ice Cream Sandwiches With Salty Chocolate Shell. Top with sliced bananas. Set aside 6 vanilla wafers for the top. I would consider myself fairly skilled in the dessert department including custards and this just wasn't working for me. It leaves that warmth in your throat and chest that a nice whiskey gives you. I'm sure there's a box mix with your name on it somewhere. These rich, chocolatey goodness of vegan double chocolate banana muffins will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you begging for more! Product Information. First up, let me show you how I started out making this dessert. Theres a couple ways to help prevent bananas from browning: Hot or cold? And Id love for you to follow me on Pinterest! I love using my good silver for hot and cold things because it takes on the temperature of the food. I follow the instructions and made no substitutes. Its the perfect flavor for a day on the lake with your nearest and dearest, or a little taste of home-cooked goodness. I was willing to see how it tasted tho but NO will never make this again, its the worst ever! Beat for several minutes, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed. Just a little so as not to change the flavor. It's delicious! Oh Amy - you have me cracking up reading your comment! Line the bottom of a 139-inch baking dish with a single layer of cookies (its okay if they overlap slightly). Just a little so as not to change the flavor. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least one to two hours before serving so it can thicken up and the wafers can soften. Let us knowhow it was! Step 1 Line an 8"-x-8" pan with parchment paper. On the page Banana Pudding Sippin Cream search results , in addition to suggestions for recipes, tips or cooking ideas, popular searches also provide everyone with detailed information about food service and latest news. Fold banana and sweetened condensed milk mixture into warm pudding with rubber spatula (adding the banana to the warm pudding helps flavor it). Time limit is exhausted. Or give this delightful chocolate Pudding Cake recipe a try soon. (Make-ahead-dessert lovers, this ones for you!) I used a 9 X 13 Pyrex dish and I tightly covered it with Glad Press and Seal wrap then snapped on the plastic lid. To make ahead: Banana pudding can be made 1-2 days ahead of time. Next time I'll try to lighten it up a bit. The Feb. 14 dinner includes Spanish guitar music from Guitarra Azul. Thank you, Hi Myra, yes you could. Add the egg yolks and stir until smooth. On what planet is this not repulsively sweet? Add in sweetened condensed milk, pudding mix, and milk. olesmoky.com, new My other suggestions would be to perhaps make banana bread or banana cake. Ardens Garden 2 Day Detox Recipe Best Weight Loss Solution! Oh mercy - you made my day! RecipesChoice is a website that provides everything related to recipes and cooking tips to help people have great food and feel happier every time standing in their beloved kitchen. If you dare, you could just drink this straight from the bottle. Your email address will not be published. of ground cinnamon 2 cups of Cool Whip whipped topping Whisk the milk, Sippin' Cream, and, ABV 20% Product Description Banana Pudding Sippin' Cream honors a classic southern dessert bursting with flavors of, Doughnuts are usually a cheap and easy snack, but this late-night bakery works hard to make the tastiest treat on Elm Street with unique creations like a chocolate- and whipped, For a sweet ending, head to the adjacent Milk Money for housemade ice, Get the recipe: brownie bites Double-Chocolate, Vegetarian Christmas Dinner Alternatives, Rosarita Vegetarian Refried Beans Ingredients, World's Best Vegetarian Enchilada Recipe, No Bake Banana Pudding With Cream Cheese. kosher salt in a medium saucepan to combine, then whisk in 1 large egg and cup whole milk. It felt weird adding a full can of condensed milk to an already sweet pudding mix plus sweet bananas but I followed the recipe Definitely should have read the reviews first. To layer: place one-third of the vanilla wafers in a layer on the bottom of a trifle dish, large bowl or a 9x13 baking dish. Scald milk, in a large sauce pot, with a pinch of the sugar (this avoids scorching the bottom of the pot). Jessie Sheehan. I had some leftover mixture so we ate that as pudding, and it was delicious. I would love to hear your experience. I can say that it's best to refrigerate overnight. I would make this on purpose. uptownspirits.com, great Treating yourself on the evening or weekends with a refreshing cocktail is a good thing. 91-93 Gold Medal Some result to a sweet and sour cocktail, while others result to smooth cocktails. Search. Total copy, This is the richest, most decadent pudding I've ever had. Pudding. Beat egg yolks in a small bowl until smooth. Pour the pudding through a sieve or fine mesh strainer into a container, to remove any lumps and make it silky smooth. Please feel free to experience the services on our site. Allergy Friendly Recipes . Cart ( 0 ) Exact matches only . You'll love the smooth, sweet ripe banana flavor with a note of vanilla, an homage to the fruit-and-cookie classic we all know and love. Success! Beverages . Join my mailing list to receive all the latest updates from The Full Nester. 94-96 Double Gold Medal Cover tightly with plastic wrap and place the assembled dessert in the fridge for 4-8 hours. All rights reserved. Instant pudding sets up almost immediately. There was an error submitting your subscription. This banana pudding was so delicious.My chessman cookies did not soften over night or the next day. If were not in your area yet, we will be soon (and we promise itll be worth the wait). Its not a taste that country folks like myself will like. Homemade Banana Pudding 100 Days of Real Food eggs, pure vanilla extract, heavy whipping cream, vanilla wafers and 7 more Fluffy Banana Pudding Honest Cooking vanilla extract, bananas, sugar, cornstarch, lemon juice, kosher salt and 6 more Biscoff Banana Pudding Southern Lady Magazine P.O. Combine whipped cream cheese & set pudding until smooth. The pudding was delicious and a big hit with my family. And a really elevated way to enjoy banana pudding, which I happen to love. It was fantastic, but a little bit goes a very long way. Or, you could lightly coat the sliced bananas in lemon or orange juice. It's easy to mess up if you aren't paying close attention. Once fully incorporated pour the entire mixture back into the pot and place over medium heat. Place over medium-low heat and cook, whisking frequently, until the mixture comes to a low simmer and begins to thicken, 5 to 10 minutes. Continue with two more layers. Add in sweetened condensed milk, pudding mix, milk and vanilla extract. Created by Jeff Ellingson this site is designed to reflect your drinking style. Of course you can! The aroma is banana pudding, vanilla, and cream. www.qualityliquorstore.com, More Info At www.qualityliquorstore.com , tip Bananas, pineapple, pecans, and cream cheese frosting combine in this Southern classic to create a sweet and delicious masterpiece. Next time I think I'll try leaving out the extra 2 Tbsp of sugar - it was still very good as is and not too too sweet, but probably would taste just as good without it. Note: HTML is allowed. I'd like to receive the free email course. Im not sure what I did wrong. 97-100 Platinum Medal, Like me on Facebook: caskcartel.com, best This recipe reminds me of the one my mom use to make. This is the worst banana pudding recipe. instead of heavy cream. This creamy, rich Banana Pudding Recipe is a delicious, no-bake dessert! topshelfwineandspirits.com, More Info At topshelfwineandspirits.com , new I loved this recipe and so did my friends and family! It is made with rum, cream liqueur, and natural flavors and bottled at 40 proof. To assemble the banana pudding, use a 9 inch square pan, a large bowl, trifle dish or individual dishes. Believe this will reduce the runniness in the fridge. Should have watched the video and notice when applying the whip cream that the sauce had thickened. Other Appalachian Sippin Cream Recipes You can make a refreshing cocktail using different ingredients depending on the flavor you want and the whiskey you have. vanilla extract. After two days in the fridge it did get a little runny but not obnoxiously so. Top with sliced bananas, then of the pudding mixture. I have made it several times and most recently Christmas Eve. 1 1/2 cups of Banana Pudding Sippin Cream, 1 package of Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix (3.4 ounces). I understand. It's very simple, you just need to enter the search keyword "recipes + Banana Pudding Sippin Cream" then the results will be displayed as soon as you press the search button. Sprinkles, for garnish. Double Gold, 2017 WSWA Tasting Competition I love your simple sweet recipes, but this nanna puddin takes the cake! It's all about eclectic share plates here, with lots of goodies made for grazing: crispy pork belly with sour cherry jam; mussels with leek in a Mezcal cream; marinated beets with sweet-and-sour Visit banana pudding sippin cream for more new recipes, meal ideas to find new dishes for the whole family. 1/4 c.. milk. (function( timeout ) { My husband also does not like cream cheese and he tears through this. You use: I mixed the ingredients all together in a bowl with a whisk. Patti Labelle Hot Water Cornbread Recipe Make Tasty Cornbread! Scrape pudding into a large bowl with a rubber spatula and chill while you prep the banana and condensed milk mixture (no need to cover). The recipe does state Instant Banana Pudding . I been making it old fashioned way for years, I will stick to my own recipe I have. dessert Jesse Goldstein July 19, 2014 dessert, banana, . If you continue to have issues, please contact us here. Line the bottom of the pan with vanilla wafers. Remove from heat and add a pinch of salt and vanilla extract, then add butter cubes and stir to make the mixture rich and super glossy. This recipe has been updated and may differ from what was originally published or broadcast. So if that can be transformed into an ice cream, uh, yes, please. 2. Your email address will not be published. Use Appalachian sippin cream recipes, and you will make a flavorful cocktail using your favorite whiskey and cream. Keep your mixer on low speed at first so the milk doesn't fly everywhere. You could also make our stabilized whipped cream which is similar to cool whip, but homemade! Youll love the smooth, sweet ripe banana flavor with a note of vanilla, an homage to the fruit-and-cookie classic we all know and love. these links. Fold in two-thirds of the whipped cream. It will help you make a refreshing cocktail with chocolate cream. She knows her banana pudding, for sure. Yes . This cream liqueur offers a deep, rich taste paired with an ultra-smooth finish sure to satisfy the banana-lover in everyone. You can use half-and-half in place of whole milk. The cheese ruins it too. Beat for several minutes, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed. Refrigerate for an hour or more, until chilled. So I screwed up there. I received a number of compliments on how good it was. *Nutrition facts are an estimate and not guaranteed to be accurate. Final Layer. To serve, slice and serve with an offset spatula. This was extremely sweet. Last week I told you about my new Poptail obsession after I got a popsicle maker set. I bet it did look beautiful in your bowl! The men of my church cook a Country Breakfast for our church members on Easter morning to serve before the service. Add another single layer of vanilla wafers, then spread 1/2 of the pudding mixture over top. The finish brings a mild sting with brown sugar, rum, banana pudding, Nilla Wafer and whipped cream taste. Required fields are marked *, My name is Aimee and Im the author here behind Shugary Sweets! (You will not use the entire box of cookiesthe extras are the chefs treat!). Thanks so much for the quick reply, Ill definitely be making this soon . I made a second batch and no change, runny pudding despite triple checking quantities and cooking the milk and cornstrached a little longer. ENJOY. I think Banana Pudding (Nanner Puddin' as we call it) is just one of those things that has to be homemade. 2 packages Pepperidge Farm Chessmen cookies, 1 package (8 ounce) cream cheese, softened, 1 can (14 ounce) sweetened condensed milk, 1 box (5 ounce) Instant Banana cream pudding mix ***. I chose to use Cool Whip for my banana pudding, but if you want to use a homemade whipped cream that would work too. ); Having made custard pies all my life. Ive always eaten and enjoyed it cold, however, true southern banana pudding is served warm, with meringue on top! Bananas wont turn brown when slicing?Is it best to cut them first an cover store in fridge till ready? In fact I get requests to make it all the time. Freeze for several hours or overnight for ice cream consistency. 9. This can be made up to 24 hours ahead of time, however for best results should be eaten within two days. The Country Cook is not a dietician or nutritionist, and any nutritional information shared is an estimate. Untraditional Vanilla Recipes . Store banana pudding covered with plastic wrap in the refrigerator. I like the velvety richness mascarpone imparts, but if you are team cream cheese (another banana pudding secret ingredient), go for it. To freeze: For best results, freeze only the pudding and assemble the banana pudding once its thawed. Im 80. If you dip your banana slices into lemon juice it makes the bananas last longer and not turn brown as soon not to mention the twang that it gives your banana pudding is delicious.